Morality in the Martial Arts by KJN Ronald Stone
"The ethical man knows it is wrong to cheat, while the moral man would simply not cheat. (Ducky on NCIS) People demonstrate prosocial and moral behavior when they share, help, co-operate, communicate, sympathize or in otherwise they demonstrate an ability to care about others.
While morals tend to be driven by personal beliefs and values, there are certainly some common morals that most people agree on, such as:
Always telling the truth.
Not destroying the property of others.
Being courageous spiritually as well as physically
Keeping your promises.
Refusing to cheat.
Treating others as you want to be treated.
Not judging without all the facts.
The above bears a remarkable resemblance to the tenets of
the martial arts as based on Korean Warrior Ideology adapted from the book, MooYe Dobo TangJi, written in the 1400s. Here they laid out:
Original Taekwondo Moral Principles
Be loyal to your country.
Be obedient to your parents.
Be loving between husband and wife.
Be cooperative between brothers.
Be respectful to your elders.
Be faithful between friends.
Establish trust between teacher and student.
Always respect all living things.
Never retreat in battle.
Always finish what you start.
Martial artists are no longer thought of as merely brute fighters, but rather as patriotic warriors and guardians and protectors of the citizenry. Just as most military services have a code of conduct and penalties for violation of moral standards such as cheating on academy exams, adultery, stolen valor etc. the martial arts have their tenents. Sadly, however there is little repercussions today for behavior that violates these tenents. When one examines the violations of moral issues that surrounds the martial arts of today one could include such things as: Misrepresentation of one's credentials and skills to gain admittance to an organization or to attract students. Fraud whether financial or though some sort of falsification Immoral behavior towards students, relatives, or other members of the martial arts community.
Illegal activity such as use or distribution of illegal drugs, sexual improprieties, drunken behavior, or things such as assault and battery etc.
Activities or behavior which brings dishonor privately or publicly to the parent organization.
In the past sadly there have been cases of sexual abuse in select martial arts schools, brutality towards innocent students or lower ranks, and several other behaviors that have brought shame and disrepute to the martial arts. Some instructors have sold rank or claimed rank from non-recognized institutions or worse yet have even invented rank. One such school even posted a framed certificate from the Shaolin Temple establishing credentials for the instructor. This was impressive until someone who spoke Chinese realized it was a framed receipt for imported Chinese fireworks.
In another case a Korean instructor proudly referred to his Kukkiwon master’s certificate on the wall of his dojang. Proudly that is until a Grandmaster fluent in Korean read it for what it really was, namely a framed copy of his Korean army discharge papers.
When they say that one bad apple ruins the barrel they may have been thinking of martial arts in the west. Without a legal or governing body some “martial artists” motivated by greed or ego have betrayed the tenents of the martial arts by unscrupulous behavior in the realization that there would be
no repercussions. With the advent of the international communities uniting though the Internet and establishing legitimate parent standards it is hoped that soon there will be such repercussions and penalties for these actions.
Truthfully however morality must be taught, learned by following good example, and accepted early on. Honesty is the best policy, but it must be felt internally since mere punishment is usually not enough for an immoral individual.
Dr. Ronald Stone, 7th dan HaeMuKwan Hapkido
American Dragon Korean Martial Arts
Be sure to follow us on social media.